LoveDemBoys' review
Does Rookie Guys deliver what it promises on the outside?
On the outside, RookieGuys.com looks like any other above average gay porn site, and certainly it's one with some good membership options, including a trial, 3-day membership for just $1.95. Once inside the site as a member, it's a bit confusing as you try to figure out where all the photos and video are hiding; but once you do, there's a lot of different porn to enjoy.What's good about Rookie Guys? What needs improvement?
The worst part about this site is the structure for navigating it. Once on the member's page there's no simple click-ons for videos, photos and the like... instead you have to scroll down to see the options for websites for indeed RookieGuys doesn't just feature Rookie Guys, but it has access to sub-sites including so-called "Reality Sites" of Gay College Sex Parties, Twinks for Cash, His First Huge Cock, His First Gay Sex, and much more. So in effect, you get just under a dozen sites for the one admission price to RookieGuys.com, but they aren't separate--the models are shared among them to some degree, and all of the sites are operated by the same parent company as far as I can tell.Once you figure out how to go to each of the individual sub-sites, and back to the main member page (which isn't intuitive some of the time), you'll find a number of hot videos spread among the sites... making it a good value for your membership fee overall.
In addition to these offerings, the website has a "marketplace" where you can, as far as I can tell, get access to even more sites for a small fee, and bonus content that enables you to surf even more gay porn sites for free access.
How is Rookie Guys unique?
The number of sub-sites and access to other sites from the main, RookieGuys.com site is rather unique and phenomenal... but to figure it all out does take some time, time better spent on downloading content and jacking-off... but it's worth it because of the varied amount of video available.Not all of it is what I found to my liking (Asians and twinks), but there was enough of these types to make it worthwhile for me... and with various fetishes included in the content, as well as a diversity of the type of guys performing, it's overall a good value.
What do paying users recieve for their money?
You have four options for membership, none of them with re-occurring billing (yea!): a 3-day trial for $1.95, and fixed 30-, 60- and 90-day memberships at reasonable costs, especially compared to other gay porn sites that have less content.As far as I can see, this is a video only site, until you get off to some of the sub-sites that are in the bonus content section. The guys vary in type from twinks in the 18-22 category, to buff gym guys 25-35, to tattooed and emo-type boys of various age.
In a nutshell, RookieGuys is worth a 30-day membership to download the content that fits your fancy, and perhaps even a longer membership since they do seem to update at least weekly.
Other GayGeek reviews of Rookie Guys
NewsBoy's review 
September 20, 2009
This is meant to be guys finding and seducing gay first timers. However, so many of these guys are recognisable from other sites, that there's little chance that many are having their first gay sex. Read full review
Porn Yogi's review
September 7, 2009
Rookieguys.com advertises itself as a site featuring videos of guys getting their first taste of gay sex. If you believe that, I have a bridge to sell you. Great terms. However, you shouldn't let that discourage you from checking out this site. There is a decent-sized collection of videos featuring mostly young and attractive, but by no means model-perfect, lads having their way with each other. The amateur models are sometimes from Eastern Europe or Latin America. Other times they are local boys. The sex is mostly vanilla, nothing exceptional or off the beaten path. Performances, as they are wont to be in amateur sites, vary in their skill and intensity. The site also has a variety of other features in addition to the basic video catalog. Read full review
Lab Ratt's review
September 2, 2009
"Rookie Guys features hot gay guys finding and seducing gay first timers into having gay anal sex with each other while it's all recorded on video." I don't buy the "first timer" thing, but hey, it's a fantasy I'll go with it. The are hot guys having anal sex with other hot guys, so technically it does deliver on what it promises, it just doesn't deliver much of what it promises. The amount of content is surprisingly tiny. Only three pages of updates are available to members. (I am only reviewing Rookie Guys, and not its bonus and sister sites.) Read full review
